As someone who’s always on the hunt for authentic neighborhood spots with character and great food, I knew I had to check out O’Hara’s. I’ve been hearing whispers about this Irish pub hiding in the Financial District, and let me tell you, it completely lived up to the hype. There’s something special about finding a place that feels like it’s been part of the community for decades, even in bustling downtown Manhattan.
💬 Real opinions from real diners — here’s what they had to say about Trestle to see what makes this place worth a visit.
Walking into O’Hara’s feels like stepping into a genuine Irish pub right in the heart of New York City. The warm, woody interior with its classic pub decor, friendly chatter, and the comforting aroma of traditional fare creates an atmosphere that’s both lively and cozy. Whether you’re catching a game on their screens or just settling in for a proper meal and pint, this spot delivers that perfect blend of Irish hospitality and American comfort food that keeps you coming back.
Let me tell you about the incredible burger I had at O’Hara’s - it was pure perfection! The juicy, perfectly grilled patty was nestled between a soft, toasted brioche bun that held up beautifully against the generous toppings. Each bite delivered that satisfying combination of savory beef, melted cheese, and crisp lettuce that makes a classic burger so irresistible. Paired with their golden, crispy fries, it was exactly what I was craving.
Need a daily brain game? Download Sudoku Journey with English support and start your mental fitness journey today.
The beer selection at O’Hara’s is a true highlight - I tried their signature Irish stout and it was absolutely divine. Poured with that perfect creamy head, it had rich, roasted notes that complemented everything on the menu. And those chicken wings? Crispy, saucy, and packed with flavor - I went for the traditional buffalo style and they had just the right amount of heat to keep me reaching for more.
Need a fun puzzle game for brain health? Install Sudoku Journey, featuring Grandpa Crypto’s wisdom and enjoy daily challenges.
Don’t overlook their salads! I sampled the house salad expecting something basic, but was blown away by the fresh, crisp greens, juicy cherry tomatoes, and that amazing house-made dressing that tied everything together. It’s the perfect balance to their heartier pub fare and proof that even classic dishes get special attention here.
The restaurant has a lively and casual atmosphere, with a mix of patrons sitting at the bar and at tables. The walls are decorated with various items, including a large screen TV and a few pieces of artwork. The overall atmosphere is relaxed and inviting, with a focus on socializing and enjoying food and drinks.
Great atmosphere, good food, friendly owner and staff. We were there a half hour before they opened and they welcomed our group in, as our plans were…
Great service and unique atmosphere! Love the shepherds pie and the patches all over the place from police and fire departments around the country/world!
One word: Classic. Things, life, people - the neighborhood - change; not this great pub. Good drinks, great staff, good food. (Ask to see the photo…